Criticism

Pakistani digital creator Haya Talha, the eldest daughter of veteran actress Shagufta Ejaz, has found herself at the center of a major social media controversy. Known for her warm personality, engaging daily vlogs, and cooking videos, Haya has built a strong online following with over 131,000 YouTube subscribers. However, a recent clip from one of her vlogs has sparked intense criticism and backlash from viewers across social media platforms. Who Is Haya Talha? For those unfamiliar, Haya Talha is a Pakistani lifestyle vlogger who currently lives in the United Kingdom with her husband Dr. Talha and their adorable son, Kyan. Her family, including her mother Shagufta Ejaz, often visits her in the UK, and fans enjoy watching their heartwarming family moments. Haya’s content, which often includes motherhood tips, home routines, and recipes, has helped her gain loyal followers who appreciate her down-to-earth personality. The Viral Video That Sparked Outrage The controversy began when a short clip from Haya Talha’s vlog started circulating on Facebook. In the video, Haya can be seen putting her baby’s pacifier in her mouth before giving it back to her son, Kyan. What might have been a casual moment for the vlogger quickly turned into a heated debate online. Social media users reacted strongly, calling the act unhygienic and unsafe for the baby. Many pointed out that adults carry bacteria and viruses in their mouths that can be harmful to infants, whose immune systems are still developing. One concerned user wrote, “An adult’s mouth contains thousands of germs. A baby’s immune system isn’t strong enough to handle them — this can easily cause infections.” Another commented, “We don’t even touch the nipple side of pacifiers, let alone put it in our mouths!” The criticism didn’t stop there — some users went as far as calling her a “careless mother”, while others made sarcastic remarks about her parenting choices. One person wrote, “It’s okay that you gave the pacifier from your mouth, but please don’t give your dog’s pacifier to the baby next time — anything can be expected from vloggers these days.” Public Reaction: Divided Opinions While many criticized Haya for being careless, a few fans came to her defense, saying the backlash was exaggerated. They argued that parents sometimes act out of instinct and that the moment was likely harmless. Still, the majority opinion leaned toward concern for baby hygiene, especially from a public figure who influences young mothers. This incident also reignited the ongoing debate about family vloggers sharing intimate family moments online. Critics believe that influencers need to be more careful about what they post, as even small actions can trigger public scrutiny and affect their credibility. Haya Talha’s Journey as a Digital Creator Before this controversy, Haya was widely admired for her positive and family-friendly content. Her vlogs often featured her home life in the UK, cooking sessions, and candid moments with her husband and son. As the daughter of the legendary Shagufta Ejaz, Haya had already attracted attention from Pakistani audiences eager to see the next generation of celebrity families online. Despite the backlash, many fans still appreciate her authenticity and relatable lifestyle, hoping she continues to create content while being mindful of public perception. Conclusion: Lessons from the Viral Moment Haya Talha’s viral pacifier clip serves as a reminder that social media can amplify even the smallest moments — especially for influencers with large audiences. In today’s digital world, where every action is open to public judgment, creators must balance personal authenticity with social responsibility. While Haya has yet to officially respond to the criticism, this incident highlights the challenges of being a public figure and a parent in the age of online transparency. Whether the backlash fades or sparks further debate, one thing is certain — Haya Talha remains one of Pakistan’s most talked-about digital creators this week.